It is our goal to create an awards organization where the recipients of the awards would be determined by The Pinball Awards Judging Panel, rather than determined by a popular vote. The judges will be comprised of pre-vetted pinball hobbyist media such as podcasters, streamers, video creators, writers, etc. In the effort for transparency, all judges, nominations, and vote tallies will be public.
Eligibility Requirements: To be eligible for the 2022 Pinball Awards, the pinball machine must have been shipped from 12/1/2021 to 12/1/2022.
The Pinball Awards (TPA) Committee is super excited to present The Pinball Awards for 2022 (formerly known as the Pinball Awards)! This year we're opening up the judging pool to include a public vote component. Much like The Game Awards, for 2022 we have decided the public component will influence 10% of the total result (with the hobbyist personality judges being reduced from their 100% for the prior two years to 90%). We believe this change will preserve our goals on award allocation (keeping it above a simple popularity contest thanks to the judges' role) while also providing a way for every interested member of the pinball hobby to participate.
The Pinball Awards Judging Panel will be comprised of any Pinball Hobbyist Personality who meets the criteria below. The TPA Governing Committee will vet each applicant around the eligibility requirements. All Judges will be identified by name and organization publicly on this site to ensure transparency of the judging pool. However, the judge's final votes will be kept confidential. A list of declined judges and reasons why will be retained but not published. If an issue arises around someone being excluded the reasons why may then be made public. Once a person qualifies as a TPA Judging Panel Judge, they will receive the secure online voting ballot via email where they will vote for their Category Award choices.
To ensure The Pinball Awards are as unbiased as possible we strive to keep conflicts of interest in the judging pool as small as possible. This requires exclusions in the selection criteria. Any individual contracted or employed by an industry manufacturer that was responsible for the development or creation of physical or intellectual contributions. Moreover, any employee who had an employee/manufacturer relationship but was terminated by either party in the 12 months prior.
The Excellence in Pinball Awards Judges are comprised of the same judges as the Category Awards. It is our goal to prevent the Excellence Awards from becoming a popularity contest among those nominated. To prevent a popular vote run off from happening, the TPA Governing Committee has determined to allow the judges a write-in style of vote for any one they see fit in a specific Excellence Award Category.
Each Judge can vote one individual per Excellence Category on their ballot. They may also decline to vote by leaving the write-in blank. Once the ballots are submitted, the write-ins votes will be totaled, and a winner chosen.
Top 3 finishers for each category will be considered 'Nominees' and will be posted on this website prior to the Crystals being awarded.
The list of write-in votes will remain confidential to prevent future vote lobbying, judge intimidation, and bias.
This award honors a pinball streamer(s) that has displayed ‘Excellence in Pinball’ by significantly contributing to the sense of community in pinball, has innovated in terms of technology in broadcasting, worked to grow the community, has consistently engaged virtually on streaming platforms, built a professional and positive brand, and who is an ambassador to the hobby of pinball.
This award honors the pinball podcast that has displayed ‘Excellence in Pinball’ by providing consistent content, unique creative license, technical achievement in editing and sound production and furthered the hobby of pinball in a positive way.
This award honors a pinball writer that has displayed ‘Excellence in Pinball’ by publishing a pinball article of significance, be it fiction or non-fiction, formally printed or online and has built the literary portfolio of the hobby of pinball.
This award honors a pinball photographer that has displayed ‘Excellence in Pinball’ by publishing photography with an emphasis on pinball, where technical achievement is displayed and has advanced the photographic presence of the hobby of pinball.
This award honors a pinball videographer that has displayed ‘Excellence in Pinball’ by publishing videos featuring pinball content, whose ability to capture an event or communicate a pinball-oriented message is exceptional, where technical achievement and innovation is on display and has advanced the presence of the hobby of pinball in a visual medium.
This award honors a pinball social media provider(s) that has displayed ‘Excellence in Pinball’ by consistently engaging virtually on one or more social media platforms, has a significant social media following, worked to grow the social media footprint of pinball, has built a professional, positive brand, and who is a representative of the hobby to those on social media platforms outside of pinball.
The Harry Williams Legacy Award is awarded to an individual in recognition of their designs, programming, innovations, boldness, business acumen, or industry leadership. This individual, who over a period of years has made a substantial and lasting contribution to the industry of pinball.
Given The Pinball Awards have a goal of positive promotion of the pinball hobby, there are a list of disqualifying behaviors. This list is applied by the TPA's Governance Committee (ballot vote) and the Excellence Awards (write-in process).
Below is a list of conditions that the TPA Governance Committee have deemed to make a potential recipient ineligible for a Category or Excellence Award. If the top vote-getter is in violation, the next highest vote-getter not in violation will receive the award. It will be publicly declared if this happens for transparency, but the name of the violator will be redacted from the announcement for privacy reasons.
The ineligibility criteria are as follows:
Annually, The Pinball Awards Governing Committee will induct pinball machines
(not individuals or design teams), voted on by the pinball community to the Pinball Machine Hall of Fame.
Machines must:
- Have flippers
- Machines prior to 1995 must have a production run of 500+ machines
- Cannot include novelty machines
- Pro/Premium/LE machines are included as one machine
The This Week In Pinball Yearly Awards (TWIPYs) are a great part of the hobby and are a People's Choice style award, which means everyone online with the voting link can vote for their favorites. Conversely, The Pinball Awards are a blended Critics Choice style of awards modeled after the wildy success Game Awards. We've created a pre-vetted judging pool with a 90% weighting. This is comprised of the 'Pinball Hobbyist Personalities'. This is followed by a 10% weighting of a vetted public vote.
This Week In Pinball does an amazing job of hosting the TWIPYs, a People's Choice style award. Everyone should be proud of what TWIP brings to the hobby in terms of community engagement, energy, and quality. Pinball is an awesome hobby to be a part of and TPN wants to continue to diversify the various ways those who put so much into the hobby are celebrated. The best way to expand the hobby awards is adding a Blended Critic's Choice style award.
The Excellence Awards are designed to be a recognition of innovation and creativity in pinball, NOT a TPN provider celebration. Nominations will be made by pre vetted judging pool of 'Hobbyist Personalities' and the Public Voters weighting.
What is the New Methodology?: The committee is always looking to expand our awards show, build on diversity and inclusion to better represent the hobby. In addition, by add more data points and engage more of the greater pinball community we can be a better reflection of the hobby! Winners are determined by a blended vote between the vetted Pinball Hobbyist Personality Judging Pool voting (90%) and public voting (10%)
It is important to The Pinball Awards Committee that the winners are not 'socially engineered', the voting system isn't exploited, and the vote represent the pinball hobby. The blended methodology provides a more credible and authentic winner. The This Week In Pinball Yearly Awards (TWIPYs) are a great part of the hobby and are a People's Choice style award, which means 100% of the vote is public. We do not want to be the TWIPYs and everyone should be proud of what TWIP brings to the hobby in terms of community engagement, energy, and quality.
+1 812-457-9711
info@thepinballindustryawards.com